Punch and Judy Politics
30.04.2008
Many things in politics are distinctly distasteful – Guido brings us an example for today - but Punch and Judy politics at PMQs is a different matter; it’s supposed to be a bear pit. Sometimes, the opportunities presented shouldn't be missed. The pithy question Cameron asked Labour MPs last week - about having a 'loser not a leader' - sticks in the mind, not because it's aggressive, undignified and borderline rude, but because with Brown mired in mess as he is at the moment, it resonates, and not least with the backbenchers ahead of tomorrow’s local elections. Vince Cable’s “From Stalin to Mr Bean” comment is a great example of this style, and politics would be the worse without it.
I also think that Cameron’s view of Punch and Judy politics has changed with his opponent. Faced with Teflon Tony, it probably was a safer course of action to play the serious card. But how do you out-do Gordon Brown, son of the manse, at being serious? And Brown is so much more ponderous than Blair; he’s easily out-manoeuvred at the dispatch box. No wonder Cameron feels the time is right to return to slinging punches.





